Different parameters are currently utilised to describe the severity of hepatic dysfunction, and are included below:
A. Model for end-stage liver disease (MELD) score (not appropriate for patients under the age of 12)rr
This may be a more accurate method but is less accessible to most clinicians because it involves calculating the score. The MELD score uses serum creatinine, serum bilirubin and INR (international normalized ratio), but the actual calculation is complex and requires log scale. For ease of use, several online calculators are readily available for calculating the MELD score, such as the Lille Model. However, it is worth noting that this model was developed for predicting survival in patients with cirrhosis and not for dosing.
B. Child-Pugh scorerrr
| Child-Pugh score (for adults) |
| Parameter |
Score |
| 1 point |
2 points |
3 points |
| Ascites |
none |
mild (medically controlled |
moderate or severe (poorly controlled) |
| Bilirubin |
less than 35 micromol/L
(less than 2 mg/dL) |
35 to 50 micromol/L
(2 to 3 mg/dL) |
greater than 50 micromol/L
(greater than 3 mg/dL) |
| Albumin |
greater than 35 g/L |
28 to 35 g/L |
less than 28 g/L |
| INR |
less than 1.7 |
1.7 to 2.3 |
greater than 2.3 |
| Encephalopathy |
none |
Grade 1 to 2 (medically controlled) |
Grade 3 to 4 (poorly controlled) |
Interpretation of Child-Pugh score
The sum of the five scores from the above table is used to assign a Child-Pugh grade of A, B or C. This grade is used to gauge mortality using the following table:
| Grade |
Score |
Description |
1 year survival |
2 year survival |
| A |
5 to 6 |
Indicates a well functioning liver |
100 % |
85 % |
| B |
7 to 9 |
Indicates significant functional compromise |
80 % |
60 % |
| C |
10 to 15 |
Indicates a decompensation of the liver |
45 % |
35 % |
Depending on hepatic clearance and the therapeutic index of the drug, dose adjustments or drug avoidance may be required in grades B or C chronic liver disease. The Child-Pugh score should be reassessed when clinically indicated, as the patient's clinical condition may improve or deteriorate.
C. NCI-organ dysfunction working group (ODWG)
The National Cancer Institute-sponsored Organ Dysfunction Working Group is leading an effort to formally assess promising or recently approved agents in patients with organ dysfunction and to develop dosing guidelines for these agents.r They have used different criteria which utilise two objective and readily measurable laboratory parameters, specifically: total serum bilirubin and aspartate aminotransferase (AST).
A small study has shown that there is some correlation between the Child-Pugh and NCI-ODWG criteria.r
| Group |
A |
B |
C |
D |
E |
| Liver function |
Normal |
Mild |
Moderate |
Severe |
Liver transplant |
| Total bilirubin |
< ULN |
B1: < ULN
B2: > 1 to 1.5 x ULN |
> 1.5 to 3 x ULN |
> 3 x ULN |
Any |
| SGOT/AST |
< ULN |
B1: > ULN
B2: Any |
Any |
Any |
Any |
Note:
- Patients with Gilbert's syndrome often have elevated total and unconjugated serum bilirubin which is usually less than 50 micromol/L. Chemotherapy dose does not need to be modified except for irinotecan (dose reduction).
- INR may be prolonged in patients without liver disease due to administration of coumarin anticoagulants (warfarin) or occasionally due to administration of antibiotics.